Must a garden have flowers? Must it have trees and shrubs? Must it have plants at all?
I think most people would say yes. But consider England’s great landscape gardens. Some of those designed by Lancelot ‘Capability’ Brown in the late 1700s had few if any flowers. And what about that masterpiece of garden art, the Ryoan-ji garden in Kyoto? This garden from the late 1400s contains only sand, rock and small islands of moss.
 |
| This image of the Ryoan-ji’s Zen garden is from Wikipedia. |
So, is “garden” simply a word to be defined according to our cultural biases, or are there other qualities that define it?
Fifteen stones on white raked gravel make up the Ryoan-ji Zen garden in Kyoto. The composition is stark and, for me, was thought-provoking. Wherever I stood, I could not see all the stones at the same time. What inspired the designer to place the stones in that way? Many people have speculated on this question. Treatises have probably been written about the meaning of the stones and their placement. But whatever its meaning, the garden had a mysterious, almost hypnotic effect on me. And I believe my response was typical.
Claude Cormier’s Blue Stick Garden is far from the Zen-inspired Ryoan-ji, in time, space and purpose. The Blue Stick Garden takes the colour of a plant as its starting point. Shades of blue found in the Himalayan blue poppy, symbol of the Reford Gardens at Metis, appear on three sides of ordinary wooden sticks. On the fourth side, shades of orange derived from the colour of the centre of the poppy deliver a simple and delightfully effective chromatic shock. In 2000, at the inaugural season of the Metis International Garden Festival, the sticks were arranged much as the flower borders of Elsie Reford’s 1920s garden would have been, graduated in height, with the shortest flower/sticks in front and the tallest in the back. The arrangment of the sticks has changed as the piece has traveled from garden to garden, yet each arrangement has harkened back to the spirit of colour and movement embodied by Reford’s Edwardian and Jekyll-inspired borders.
 |
| Claude Cormier’s Blue Stick Garden is now installed on the lawn near Estevan Lodge at the Reford Gardens in Metis, Quebec. |
Are these coloured sticks a garden? I say yes, emphatically yes. Cormier’s creation is a contemporary take on ‘garden,’ evoking a period in the history of garden design that continues to shape our notions of what a garden is, or should be. And as a garden made in the opening year of the 21st century, it fulfills a garden’s role of reflecting the ideas of the era in which it is created.Gardens exist within a framework of time and place. The word itself has a history — and that history colours how we think about what a garden is, or can be. Its root comes from the Persian pairidaeza (which has an obvious linguistic connection to our word paradise) and refers to an enclosure. Historically, this is understandable: when the world ‘outside’ was dangerous, a walled off space ensured safety for the people who lived there and the plants they grew. As the word moved through various languages (Anglo-Saxon geard; Old Norse garör; Middle English gardin, from the French jardin; Old German gart), it retained that sense of an enclosed place.
 |
| A garden ‘plot’ from the 2008 garden festival at Chaumont-sur-Loire. A witty take on an enclosed space. I wish I could remember the designer’s name. |
In medieval times, the walled garden, or hortus conclusus, offered safety. In Edwardian times, the motivation shifted. The walls of a garden were like blindfolds, hiding the unpleasant realities of the world beyond. Contrast that blinkered view with the expansive spirit of 18th century England, where ha-ha walls went underground, hiding themselves to allow an open view onto the world beyond. Or with the change from the enclosed space of an Italian Renaissance gardens to the openness of the gardens less than a hundred years later, when baroque became the rage.
Reverse the question. If flowers, or any type of living plant material, are necessary for a space to be a garden, does their presence necessarily create a garden? If so, why don’t we call a farm field a garden, or a stretch of ‘natural’ woodland?
The difference is intention. A garden is a designed space. Whether it has flowers or not, it has been made for a reason. It is not natural but an artificial construct, shaped with a purpose in mind. Over the years, that purpose has shifted, as cultures and economies have changed. In today’s world we may want to make gardens into soothing retreats or refuges from the cotidian. But they needn’t be. They needn’t be picturesque, or look natural, or aim to imitate nature. Gardens today can be minimal or maximal. They can be big or small, full of flowers or without a single bloom.
Gardens can be whatever we want them to be.
 |
| Traffic jams ahead? These converging lines appeared on the lake a few years ago. |
In winter, when I am bereft of flowers, when shrubs are mostly bare or hidden under snow, I think about these things. I think about the many different types of gardens, and how the names we use for them influence how we think about the space itself. Flower gardens, vegetable gardens, rock gardens, moss gardens. Botanical gardens, zoological gardens, sculpture gardens.
I try to think outside the box — and beyond the cliché — to allow my mind to range freely. I do this in the hope that thinking more freely will lead somewhere: to a garden that is more individual, more peculiar perhaps, but also more particular to me and mine.
I think this is an ambition that many of us share. We want our gardens to reflect something about ourselves, to be personal statements rather than copycat versions of the predictable.
Or am I wrong?
Just love it! Thinking outside the box, free range, organic and definitely not stuck in the produce section. Expression in a given space, a garden, your expression! This brings to mind The Gates in New York. http://www.nytimes.com/ref/arts/design/GATES-REF.html
I missed my chance to see The Gates but from all reports the experience was magnificent. So, were The Gates a garden?
Is Claude Cormier’s Blue Stick Garden a garden? I would say yes. The Gates in Central Park a garden, I would say yes. Gardening on a large scale, a park. Butchart Gardens a garden yes but more on the scale of a park. My definition of a garden is from a flower pot to 750 acres!! How’s your Italian coming along?
There are a lot of gardens where I think, “A nice place to visit, but I wouldn’t want to live there.” For me, yes, a garden has to have flowers, but not only flowers, also shapes and textures interacting with color, and for me, personally, it’s not a satisfying garden without a path. Have you ever read The Wild Braid by Stanley Kunitz? “What you plant in your garden reflects your own sensibility, your concept of beauty, your sense of form. Every true garden is an imaginative construct, after all.” Julie Moir Messervy’s archetypal spaces also resonate with me–the idea that there are such things, I mean. Some of her archetypes mean more to me than others.
Kathy, I haven’t read Stanley Kunitz but I definitely will. I agree entirely with the quote. Julie Moir Messervy’s book about archetypes remains one of my all time favourites.
I would love to have dozens of colored sticks to put out in a winter garden — then bring them back in for the warm months.
Great quote by Kunitz above. I gave the book to my mother years ago, but now I have ordered it for myself.
I’m ordering the book for myself, too. I like the idea of sticks in winter… may even do it.
Yes, you are right.
I just read this in David Cooper’s book, A Philosophy of Gardens, and thought of this post again:
“A lorry-driver, delivering a load to the house at Lunuganga of the great Sri Lankan architect and garden designer Geoffrey Bawa, took an admiring look at the very ‘natural’, ‘informal’, and almost flower-less garden, and then remarked, ‘This would be a lovely place to have a garden.'”
Nice information! I am intimidated by the excellence of information. There are a lot of high-quality funds here. I am sure I will visit this site again soon. I know something information, to know you can click here
Lawn services brisbane
Lawn mowing services brisbane
Great Content.I have appreciate with getting lot of good and reliable information with your post…….
Thanks for sharing such kind of nice and wonderful collection……again, beautiful 🙂 I love reading your posts. They make me happy . . I know something information, to know you can click here
gardening Brisbane
garden maintenance Brisbane
Thank you for the fantastic article. The place else could anyone get that kind of info in such a perfect means of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I am at the search for such information. To get new information visit here
SNAIL WHITE CREAM
BANGLADESHI RECIPES BLOG
SNAIL WHITE CREAM REVIEW
Congratulation,for the post.These icon sets are very exclusive,specially its attract for 3d & stylish looks.i appreciated all of your collection.thank for sharing to 1st webdesigner.I know something data, to know you can click here
How to increase sexual desire
How to increase libido in women
This is an informative post review. I am so pleased to get this post article. I was looking forward to get such a post which is very helpful to us. Keep it up. . I know something information, to know you can click here
Health
Environmental
Occupational safety
Thankful concerning the comment. I agree. The greater part of these houses
are made essentially as disposable customer things. Resale quality is not
by any stretch of the creative ability the specialist’s need.
Mowing Brisbane
pressure cleaning brisbane
Great Content.I have appreciate with getting lot of good and reliable information with your post…….
Thanks for sharing such kind of nice and wonderful collection……again, beautiful 🙂 I love reading your posts. They make me happy . . I know something information, to know you can click here
Lawn services brisbane
pressure cleaning brisbane
Lawn mowing brisbane
Thank you for the fantastic article. The place else could anyone get that kind of info in such a perfect means of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I am at the search for such information. To get new information visit here
garden makeover
garden makeovers
This is an informative post review. I am so pleased to get this post article. I was looking forward to get such a post which is very helpful to us. Keep it up. . I know something information, to know you can click here
Mowing Brisbane
Lawn Mowing Brisbane
pressure cleaning brisbane
I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.
Feel free to visit this site … garden makeover brisbane
Hi – It’s good to read such interesting stuff on the Internet as I have been able to discover here. I agree with much of what is written here and I’ll be coming back to this website again.
Thanks again for posting such great reading material!! To get new information visit here ,,,,garden makeover brisbane,,commercial landscaping brisbane
Thanks for sharing such kind of nice and wonderful collection……again Pressure Cleaning Brisbane